Showing posts with label Islam. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Islam. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Burning Korans = Not A Good Idea

One of my readers recently asked me how Moroccans were reacting to the controversy over the proposed mosque/Islamic cultural center near Ground Zero. Honestly, no one has mentioned it since I've been back in Morocco, and I haven't brought the subject up. But I have been following the ruckus online and have been disappointed with the way the debate (shouting match?) has developed.

Since my audience is generally Western, let me start with something unfamiliar: a video making the rounds in the Francophone Muslim world that a number of my Moroccan Facebook friends have posted on Facebook.



The video begins with footage of Muslims dressed in Western style, cheering Western sports, and playing Western-inspired game shows like "Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?" while these words appear (in French):
While we sing, dance, eat, and imitate their civilization...

...look what's happening in their civilization.

It then flashes to a CNN interview with Pastor Terry Jones, whose church has decided to burn Korans in commemoration of 9/11 and protest against Islam. As the Facebook posts testify, this is far from helpful to relations between Islam and the West. The American interviewer is obviously hostile to such a stupid idea, and Pastor Jones cannot respond satisfactorily to his line of questioning. More text appears:
While a Muslim scholar does his duty...

The video then cuts to footage of Khalid Arrachid, an Islamic scholar who was apparently jailed for "defending the prophet in the Muhammed cartoon controversy". I can't find anything online to confirm he was jailed, but in this video he describes the Danish cartoons of Muhammed and then cites a Koranic passage about being "severe with the disbelievers" to demand violence against those who mock the prophet. He decries the shame and disgrace Muslims suffer, calls Muslims to show their manhood and defend the prophet, mocks the "effeminacy" of Europeans and their "freedom of expression", and laments the lack of visible leadership of Muslim nations.

After lamenting the imprisonment of this Islamic scholars for "doing his duty", the above video ends with seemingly threatening footage of a man with a gun trained on someone off screen. The last words to appear are:
Islam is a religion of peace but not of humiliation.

It's no viral sensation, but the video does have over 11,000 views now.

A Facebook group entitled "tous contre l'acte de bruler le coran le 11 septembre 2010" ("Everyone Against Burning the Koran on September 11, 2010") was started in opposition to this proposed Koran burning. Currently it has 13, 799 members. The comments on the group's page range from exhortations to defend Islam's honor a la Khalid Arrachid to quotes of Koranic ayas (verses) to prophecies that Pastor Jones and company will burn in hell to pleas for non-violence because violence would only confirm American stereotypes about Islam. It's a mixed bag, but at least some of it is quite troubling.

I draw a few observations from this Facebook activity:

1) Moroccan Teenagers Have a Liberalized, Western Outlook
Moroccan teenagers' desire to defend their religious tradition is only one of their many interests and concerns, and a good number of them actually conflict with the message of the video. The majority of items they post on their Facebook walls represent the Westernizing tendency the video decries: Western sports stars and celebrities, American music videos, and quizzes about love and sexiness. They may strongly and defensively identify as Muslim, but the way their interests and concerns are unconstrained ideologically or legally is not that different from the situation of Westerner teenagers. As time goes on, these tendencies will only strengthen. The Arab world is westernizing faster than many realize.

2) Islam Currently Has Illiberal, Violent Tendencies
The maker of the YouTube video obviously does realize how quickly this westernization is happening, and he is opposed to it. Khalid Arrachid is not alone when he opines on the victimized state of Muslims, the effeminate nature of Western culture, the manly necessity of defending Islam and its prophet, and the possible violence such a defense will require. Now his cries may fall on deaf ears among middle and upper class Moroccan youth because they are financially and politically secure, but they still are deeply angered by insults to Islam and to Mohammed. Moreover, immigrants in Europe (and to a lesser extent the United States), citizens of less developed Muslim countries, and lower class Moroccan citizens often do not share that security, and so their anger is more likely to express itself violently.

3) There Are Legitimate Questions About Islam In Pluralist Societies
These phenomena raise serious questions about how such an Islam can fit into pluralist, secular societies. Those on the right tend to ignore the nuances of these questions as they raise voices and money in crude and xenophobic populism. They gloss over cherished American values like religious freedom, freedom of association, and property rights. But those on the left similarly ignore the illiberal, violent tendencies of Islam as they work themselves into an indignantly righteous rage against the other side's crude, xenophobic populism. They fail to understand how religion works, the historical development of Western political-religious involvement, and, in their intense emotional obsession with this moment in time, the broader sweep of the complicated process of assimilation into the American mainstream.

If Catholics in America are any indication, the prognosis for a future assimilation of Muslims into an American consensus is good. Pre-Vatican II and pre-JFK, there were some very serious questions about whether Catholics, with their illiberal tendencies, could function well in a pluralist democracy. But after theological recognition of pluralist democracy and after a charismatic leader who made necessary concessions to an already existent American consensus on religion and politics, Catholics gradually became a surprisingly normal and uncontroversial part of our nation's political and religious mosaic.

Protesting an Islamic cultural center directed by a Muslim leader who goes on speaking tours for the U.S. government and burning Korans are most definitely not intelligent, serious ways to engage these questions, but even if the overly mediatized, populist right cannot address them as they should, they remain important questions. And until they are resolved as they were with Catholicism half a century ago, they will continue to inspire inarticulate and emotional resistance to Muslims.

4) There Is A Denial About The Islamic Inspiration For Terrorism
Partially as a reaction to the hateful and xenophobic reaction against Muslims as a whole, both secular Westerners and Muslims comfortable in liberal, secular society tend to ignore that attacks such as 9/11 are in fact inspired by a certain interpretation of Islam. Instead, there is a tendency among the secular elite to attribute terrorism's motivation solely to economic and political considerations.

While European colonialism of the Arab world (including Zionism), cozy relationships between the United States and Arab governments, and continuing difficult economic circumstances play important roles in Islamic terrorism, the religious motivation cannot just be swept aside. This form of terrorism is inspired, justified and praised by Muslims with a certain historical and religious hermeneutic...a hermeneutic that will not just go away with a wave of the magic wand of secular liberalism.

Of course, neither can Islam be treated as a monolithic entity, as too many conservative commentators tend to do. Only a small minority of Muslims share Al-Qaeda's ideology, although a good many may sympathize at least in part. But that doesn't detach Al-Qaeda's hermeneutic and actions from the Islamic tradition. "Islam is a religion of peace but not of humiliation", a mantra shared by most Muslims, necessarily implies violence and resistance towards liberal, pluralist Western governments at some point in time.

Since the Enlightenment, for better or for worse, religion in the Western world has been viewed more or less as an internalized set of personal convictions and beliefs. This necessarily conflicts with a religion like Islam that is less focused around orthodoxy (correct belief) than around orthopraxis (correct action). European Islamic scholar Tariq Ramadan has proposed an interesting solution to the conflict. Time will tell if his or some other synthesis will prevail in the Muslim community. In the meantime, non-Muslim Westerners are unlikely to have any positive influence in those debates, but, at the very least, we can recognize that they are happening.

Saturday, May 22, 2010

23 Foreigners Expelled Last Week

The Morocco Board News Service reports on the newest wave of expulsions, including 23 last week:
Morocco has expelled foreign Christians who tried to convert Muslims because, as a moderate Islamic state, it wants to foster "order and calm" and avoid a clash between faiths, its Islamic affairs minister said.

The government has expelled around 100 foreign Christians since March, many of them aid workers, in what Western diplomats have called an unprecedented crackdown on undercover preaching.

"These incidents (expulsions) were prompted by the activism of some foreigners who undermined public order," Religious Endowments and Islamic Affairs Minister Ahmed Toufiq told Reuters in an interview late on Thursday.

"There are some who hide their proselytism and religious activism under the guise of other activities," he said.

I found this line of reasoning interesting. Factually, it is certainly correct. And in Morocco historically concerns over "order and calm" have regularly trumped individuals' freedom of conscience or religion, even if the discussion is limited merely to Muslims. Many Moroccans point to Algeria and its civil war as an example of what happens when you don't use government force to limit religious disagreements.

Thankfully, there hasn't been a civil war in Morocco nor has there been any sort of the extreme bloodletting along religious lines that we have seen in other parts of the Middle East. That is certainly due in large part to the strong arm of the state when it comes to these issues.

That being said, other comments from Minister Toufiq strike me as disingenuous if not blatantly false.
Converting Muslims is a crime in Morocco, punishable by up to six months in jail, but the authorities generally expel foreigners accused of proselytising rather than take them to court to avoid publicity and criticism from abroad.

Muslims make up 99 percent of Morocco's population and the north African country allows freedom of worship to mostly foreign Christians and a few thousand indigenous Jews.

Toufiq said Morocco was eager to foster respect and coexistence between its different faiths, but was also "protecting its religious community".

"Morocco wants to prevent a clash or conflict between religions. It is not necessary that one religion converts believers of another religion," he said, adding that he had explained this position to representatives of other faiths.

If it is not necessary that one religion convert believers of another religion, then why do so many Moroccan Muslims try to convert me to Islam?

Upon meeting a Moroccan, the second or third question is inevitably, "Are you Muslim?" often followed by others like "Do you pray?" or "What do you think of Mohammed?" or "What do you think of the Koran?" I can't count the number of Muslims who have tried to get me to repeat the Shahada (the statement of belief in one God and Mohammed's status as prophet, which when said, makes you a Muslim).

Perhaps it's not clear to Toufiq that Muslims also try to convert others, but from my vantage point it's as clear as day.

I usually shrug these events off with a joke. Or I quote an aya from the Koran to let my new Muslim friends know that I do respect them and I want to coexist with them.

But let's be real about this: most of them want me to be a Muslim. And I wish that they had a real knowledge of the Christian gospel and not the false representation they are all taught. And any sort of honest dialogue in respect has to start from those facts.

In a state where true religious liberty existed, where freedom of conscience was actually valued, we would be able to have discussions about these subjects in mutual respect and tolerance. We would be able to speak openly and the force of the state would not interfere in those discussions nor in the decisions that resulted.

Morocco is not that kind of state.

Friday, November 27, 2009

Further Notes on Eid al Kabir

I've continued to ask a number of my Moroccan friends and students about the upcoming Eid al Kabir holiday. Yesterday, for instance, only 5 of my 14 students showed up for class. So, rather than pursuing the lesson I had planned, I led the group in a discussion about the holiday, working on the near future ('I'm going to',....'then my family's going to...', 'next we're going to...", etc.)

For Christians encountering the Eid al Adha, the other name for Eid al Kabir, we might wonder why an animal sacrifice is necessary. In Christian theology, the crucifixion of Jesus was a once for all sort of sacrifice that makes further atonement by animal death unnecessary.

However, the most common explanations for the holiday, as I've briefly outlined before, involve aspects other than atonement. Particularly, Moroccans have mentioned 1) remembering Abraham's unquestioning obedience to God, 2) spending time with family, and 3) social solidarity.

In terms of family togetherness, the holiday is a lot like Thanksgiving and Christmas all wrapped up into one. People travel to be with their extended family, often the only time of the year, and they kill an animal and eat it in every imaginable way. After the meal, visits to family and friends in the city take up much of the following few days. For most people, it seems this togetherness is the real point. Theological abstraction is always harder to grasp, I think, than the tangible reality of being with loved ones.

As for social solidarity, Muslims are commanded in the Sunna to give 1/3 of their meat to the poor of society. Sometimes, richer Muslims will even buy whole sheep for poorer families.

But family togetherness and social solidarity aside, that still leaves the question: Why kill a sheep? Why use the most universal act for appeasing God's anger to accomplish these other goals? The way it has been represented to me here puts the main emphasis on the commemoration of Abraham's obedience in his willingness to sacrifice his son out of obedience to God, and not on an attempt to appease God's righteous anger.

Islam's insistence emphasis on submission to God is demonstrated quite powerfully in the story. Abraham submits obediently to God's command to sacrifice his son, despite his reservations. When God sees that Abraham is faithful, he stops him and provides a sheep instead. From a Christian perspective, the foreshadowing of God's own sacrifice of his son and the atonement aspect are missing from this Islamic ritual of the sheep killing, but Christians should be able to appreciate the commemoration of unwavering obedience to God, even if the content and means of that obedience takes different forms in Islamic and Christian theology.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Thoughts on the Koran, Part 1

One of my goals in living in Morocco is to be able to read Arabic, particularly Classical Arabic. On an academic but also on a very real personal level, I am interested in the relationship between Islam and Christianity and how both interact with secular modernity. I tend to think that a lot of contemporary problems would not exist if we better understood these issues.

Yesterday, along with a friend, I worked through the Arabic of al-Fatiha, the first sura of the Qur'an. So I thought that I would post my translation and a few thoughts on it.

Sura 1: al-Fatiha
1. In the name of God, the Compassionate, the Merciful
2. Praise be to God, Lord of the Worlds,
3. The Compassionate, the Merciful
4. King of the Day of Religion [the Day of Judgment]
5. It is you we worship and it is you we call on for help
6. Guide us in the correct way,
7. the way of religion, of those upon whom you have had favor and not of those upon whom your anger has come nor of those who have lost the way.

A few notes:
1) This sura uses a structure that puts the accusative (objective) form first in the fifth verse, thus putting God before those who worship him, even though those who worship him are the subject of the sentence. This mirrors grammatically the structure of the relationship between God and human: even in human action and agency, God is most important.

2) The use of the word 'Deen' ('Religion') is much broader than our current sociological use of the word 'religion' in English. It is comparable to Jonathan Edwards' 18th century use of "religion" (see his 30th Resolution, for instance). It is not just a set of beliefs and practices, but rather the true way, the way of God beyond any human creations). It involves the most important things we will have to come to account for at the Final Judgment. There is just a hint of the Islamic insistence on moving beyond idolatry (putting ultimate value on something other than God) to worship of the one true God beyond all those idols. We might compare this with Jesus' harsh rebukes of the Pharisees and their tendency to miss the forest of what God wants for the trees of tradition and rules. Jesus said the Prophets and the Law were summed up in two commandments: Love the Lord your God with all your heart and soul and mind and Love your neighbor as yourself. The importance of that love and worship of God as more important than all rules and traditions (and what should be the source of any rules and traditions we do have) is shared between Islam and Christianity. As a result, avoiding idols is another similar aspect between the two faiths (although some Muslims might argue that the way Christians make images or talk of God is idolatrous). How this God beyond idols is known and worshiped are different, but the uppermost goal is central in both faiths.

3) This Sura clearly divides the world into those who seek to worship the one true God (the action of seeking it being described using the metaphor of the path or way) and those who merit God's anger and have lost the true way. This parallels Christianity as well. The difference, of course, lies in what that path is and, in the case of Christianity, who it goes through (the person of Jesus Christ). But once again, the similarities in purpose are very strong: seeking the one true God and his way.


Disclaimer:
I am in no way a Koranic scholar (nor a real Biblical scholar for that matter). These are just a few observations from my very limited understanding of the Arabic and my observations of both Christianity and Islam. I more than welcome corrections and constructive criticism.